SHARP STICK (2022)

 

Written & Directed by Lena Dunham

Where & When: Nuart Theatre, West Los Angeles, CA.  August 3, 2022  5:20 PM

Back in 2010, Lena Dunham released "Tiny Furniture", her debut feature film she wrote and directed. This semi-autobiographical, indie dramatic-comedy gave us the first taste of her quirky, self-referential voice. Dunham spoke with caustic humor about how her generation feels unsteady trying to maneuver through this modern world as a young adult. This low-budget film, which featured her mother, Laurie Simmons, a New York artist who was the big name at the time, received plenty of critical acclaim and awards, leading Dunham to collaborate with Judd Apatow and create the HBO series, "Girls" two years later.

This urban comedy expanded upon characters and ideas from "Tiny Furniture", focused on addressing the challenges facing a group of aimless, twenty-something women. After six captivating seasons, "Girls" made Dunham a bigger name, introduced us to a future star (Adam Driver) and helped open the door to shows built around unconventional female protagonists who are deeply flawed and not necessarily likable.

Now Dunham has just made her second feature film, "Sharp Stick", an offbeat, coming-of-age story of an awkward young girl who treats her sexual awakening as if she's a determined student trying hard to get a top grade in school. There are certainly some interesting, funny ideas at play here yet they are muddled due to a narrative that falls uneasily between a strange, dark comedy and an uncomfortably creepy satire.

Sarah Jo (Kristine Froseth) lives in the Hollywood area of LA with her mother, Marilyn (Jennifer Jason Leigh), a new-age, Earth mother type and her sister, Treina (Taylour Paige) who is focused on finding success through being a social media influencer. Although she's in her twenties, Sarah Jo comes across as much younger due to her sweet, Pollyanna nature. Yet underneath lurks a lustful, passionate woman with burning desires that wants to be noticed. Sarah Jo decides to set her sights on Josh (Jon Bernthal), the married, stay-at-home dad of Zach (Liam Michel Saux), the special needs child she tutors, to lose her virginity with. And while this good-natured goofball tries to resist, Josh ultimately gives in to Sarah Jo's seduction, especially after she informs him that she had a hysterectomy at fifteen.

This one-time encounter soon evolves into an actual love affair. Later, Josh introduces Sarah Jo to the world of digital pornography with her far more fascinated than aroused. But Sarah Jo is unceremoniously dumped after Josh's pregnant wife (Dunham) discovers their affair. Lost and despondent, she tries to mend her heartbreak by focusing on her favorite porn star, Vance Leroy (Scott Speedman), writing him pages of long letters seeking guidance through his sexual wisdom to help her win Josh back. Then, as a way to impress Josh, Sarah Jo makes a cute, homemade poster board listing all of the sexual acts she plans to perform with random men from A to Z, with a place to check off when completed.

Dunham has finally moved away from relying so heavily on a fictionalized version of her life in her work, moving towards characters outside of her comfort zone. But with this film, she doesn't push far enough into the absurd that feels necessary, lacking clearly defined characters and creating a false sense of female empowerment. "Sharp Stick" also doesn't have much of a cinematic scope, never feeling more than an enhanced, expanded television episode.

Froseth plays Sarah Jo as child-like and very naïve, an unbelievable trait with her growing-up in this fast-moving, modern city of Los Angeles living with her worldly mother and sister. She also comes across as a bit dim which could explain some of her behavior yet her motivations remain unclear. Dunham adds race into the story with Treina being African-American and taken in as a baby to be raised by this family due to sad circumstances. Yet there is no commentary or development from this addition with the character sidelined for much of the film, leaving a feeling that this was too much of a calculated after-thought.

"Sharp Stick" seems to be making a statement about our society's obsession with sexuality and gender politics. But Dunham's use of oddball characters, provocative comedy and feminist ideology is not clearly conceived to make this film entirely compelling or enjoyable. Yet I am glad that Dunham has returned to the big screen and that it will not be over ten years until her next feature (she has written and directed an adaptation of the children's book, "Catherine Called Birdy" for Amazon Studios due out in September). While I have not always been won over by her work, I greatly appreciate what Dunham tries to achieve, offering a bold challenge to conventional themes utilizing a commanding female perspective.